Notice Message

MBA Discussions

University Selection

zoyakhan

0

6


Nov 19, 2011 03:50

useful 0

quote

I am a fresher presently running my Dad's company.I want a degree with is more practical oriented hence I chose MBA or MSc Management.I have been given the following options by consultants here in India.
1. Aberdeen
2. Coventry
3. Sterling
Are any of these good? I have very good academic results. Should I wait for the sept intake of LBS for MSc management?
I am a fresher presently running my Dad's company.I want a degree with is more practical oriented hence I chose MBA or MSc Management.I have been given the following options by consultants here in India. 1. Aberdeen 2. Coventry 3. Sterling Are any of these good? I have very good academic results. Should I wait for the sept intake of LBS for MSc management?

Duncan

170

6140


Nov 19, 2011 06:49

useful 0

quote

No, I think there is no point going into schools without international accreditation. Look at LBS or the schools ranked by the FT.
No, I think there is no point going into schools without international accreditation. Look at LBS or the schools ranked by the FT.

zoyakhan

0

6


Nov 21, 2011 03:51

useful 0

quote

I need a course which will help my business. I don't want a job later. Also I can surely not wait for 3 years and then apply. Right now I have a letter from stirling for MBA.I will be applying to aberdeen , liverpool hope, cardiff,coventry. But how do I choose among these?
I need a course which will help my business. I don't want a job later. Also I can surely not wait for 3 years and then apply. Right now I have a letter from stirling for MBA.I will be applying to aberdeen , liverpool hope, cardiff,coventry. But how do I choose among these?

Duncan

170

6140


Nov 21, 2011 03:40

useful 0

quote

Without work experience you have two choices: either a freshers MBA without serious accreditation, or an MSc. An MSc from a ranked, accredited school will be much better. Look at these schools: http://rankings.ft.com/businessschoolrankings/masters-in-management-2011

Of the programmes you mention, I would choose either Sterling, or one of the top MSc.
Without work experience you have two choices: either a freshers MBA without serious accreditation, or an MSc. An MSc from a ranked, accredited school will be much better. Look at these schools: http://rankings.ft.com/businessschoolrankings/masters-in-management-2011 Of the programmes you mention, I would choose either Sterling, or one of the top MSc.

zoyakhan

0

6


Nov 22, 2011 06:43

useful 0

quote

Thanks for the reply. Really appreciated.
I read and concluded that MSc is more of an academic degree.Please understand I have my own company. The name of the university does not matter as much as the experience and exposure I will get from my course.I already have the letter from Stirling so is it no point applying to Coventry, Aberdeen and Cardiff? My consultant here says Coventry and Aberdeen are better than Stirling. Btw I am not going to major in Finance.Would you still suggest Stirling?
Thanks for the reply. Really appreciated. I read and concluded that MSc is more of an academic degree.Please understand I have my own company. The name of the university does not matter as much as the experience and exposure I will get from my course.I already have the letter from Stirling so is it no point applying to Coventry, Aberdeen and Cardiff? My consultant here says Coventry and Aberdeen are better than Stirling. Btw I am not going to major in Finance.Would you still suggest Stirling?

Duncan

170

6140


Nov 22, 2011 10:46

useful 0

quote

Look again at the list of MSc degrees ranked by the FT. If they were *only* academic degrees and not also management development programmes, why would students get getting salaries like $86,928 at the Universität St.Gallen, $97,635 at WHU and $73,085 at HEC? This is three times the average starting salary. Take a look at the roles these students get getting hired into: they are getting much more senior roles than graduates from the pre-experience MBAs.

Aberdeen does not require work experience for their MBAs. Coventry and Stirling do. That makes a huge difference in the quality of your classmates, and they are the major part of the experience. The Aberdeen MBA is purely taught, with no mention of major projects, personal development workshops, case study writing, internships etc (http://www.abdn.ac.uk/business/smartthinking/mba/structure.php) Stirling at least has personal development, a research project and internships (http://www.management.stir.ac.uk/study/postgraduate-courses/mba). The Coventry MBA curriculum pages are offline right now (http://wwwm.coventry.ac.uk/bes/cubs/courses/Pages/pgft_BusinessEnvironmentSociety.aspx?itemID=131&yoe=2010) but I would look carefully at support for professional development and soft skills.

Stirling, of course, ranks normally in the top third of UK universities while Coventry is one of the 'modern universities' and ranks always below average (http://www.guardian.co.uk/education/table/2011/may/17/university-league-table-2012). While now the name of the university does not matter, can you honestly say that the quality of the students, campus, professors, alumni network and facilities is unimportant? Those are what drive the rankings. And are you use you will always have your own company?
Look again at the list of MSc degrees ranked by the FT. If they were *only* academic degrees and not also management development programmes, why would students get getting salaries like $86,928 at the Universität St.Gallen, $97,635 at WHU and $73,085 at HEC? This is three times the average starting salary. Take a look at the roles these students get getting hired into: they are getting much more senior roles than graduates from the pre-experience MBAs. Aberdeen does not require work experience for their MBAs. Coventry and Stirling do. That makes a huge difference in the quality of your classmates, and they are the major part of the experience. The Aberdeen MBA is purely taught, with no mention of major projects, personal development workshops, case study writing, internships etc (http://www.abdn.ac.uk/business/smartthinking/mba/structure.php) Stirling at least has personal development, a research project and internships (http://www.management.stir.ac.uk/study/postgraduate-courses/mba). The Coventry MBA curriculum pages are offline right now (http://wwwm.coventry.ac.uk/bes/cubs/courses/Pages/pgft_BusinessEnvironmentSociety.aspx?itemID=131&yoe=2010) but I would look carefully at support for professional development and soft skills. Stirling, of course, ranks normally in the top third of UK universities while Coventry is one of the 'modern universities' and ranks always below average (http://www.guardian.co.uk/education/table/2011/may/17/university-league-table-2012). While now the name of the university does not matter, can you honestly say that the quality of the students, campus, professors, alumni network and facilities is unimportant? Those are what drive the rankings. And are you use you will always have your own company?

Mamit

0

451


Nov 23, 2011 12:58

useful 0

quote

Hi Zoya,
I would strongly recommend you to opt for a MSc good B-School rather than going for an MBA program at not accredited university. I would suggest that you can also opt for MBM at Strathclyde which will give your an option to upgrade it to MBA at later stage.
Mamit
Hi Zoya, I would strongly recommend you to opt for a MSc good B-School rather than going for an MBA program at not accredited university. I would suggest that you can also opt for MBM at Strathclyde which will give your an option to upgrade it to MBA at later stage. Mamit

zoyakhan

0

6


Nov 24, 2011 01:17

useful 0

quote

Hi.. what are the chances of getting through if I apply to the best schools like LBS , Harvard , Stanford,Insead,MIT-Sloan,etc.
I have passed my 10th , 12th and BE with Distinction.
And at 22 I am looking after a medical equipment company on my own.
Hi.. what are the chances of getting through if I apply to the best schools like LBS , Harvard , Stanford,Insead,MIT-Sloan,etc. I have passed my 10th , 12th and BE with Distinction. And at 22 I am looking after a medical equipment company on my own.

Duncan

170

6140


Nov 24, 2011 02:10

useful 0

quote

When you have 700+ on the GMAT and four or five more years' work experience, you should be an interesting candidate for those schools.
When you have 700+ on the GMAT and four or five more years' work experience, you should be an interesting candidate for those schools.

zoyakhan

0

6


Nov 24, 2011 04:49

useful 0

quote

Yes I will work on my GMAT and I will grow this company.Then may be I will have a chance.,Thanks for all the input.When I make it big you people will remember this day!
Yes I will work on my GMAT and I will grow this company.Then may be I will have a chance.,Thanks for all the input.When I make it big you people will remember this day!

zoyakhan

0

6


Nov 24, 2011 04:44

useful 0

quote

Only If I want the best will I get the best. If I have been a good student all my life and if I have big dreams.. why should I settle for something thats not the "best"
Only If I want the best will I get the best. If I have been a good student all my life and if I have big dreams.. why should I settle for something thats not the "best"

Reply to Post