Notice Message

MBA Discussions

MA/Msc vs MBA

Jul 21, 2006 02:37

useful 0

reply

this might sound pretty naive, but could i get comments on say acquiring an MA/Msc in management instead of MBA oweing to the high cost of an MBA? I mean what would be the major drawback for not doing an MBA?
Thanks!
this might sound pretty naive, but could i get comments on say acquiring an MA/Msc in management instead of MBA oweing to the high cost of an MBA? I mean what would be the major drawback for not doing an MBA? Thanks!

Marsha

0

30


Jul 22, 2006 11:36

useful 0

reply

An MA or MSc in business will not be as marketable in the business world as an MBA degree. The MBA is usually much more competetitive. It is more difficult to get into the top schools to do an MBA and the curriculum will be more rigorous in most cases. Many do an MBA after having completed an MSc. I think the "MBA" will open much more doors than any other graduate degree.
An MA or MSc in business will not be as marketable in the business world as an MBA degree. The MBA is usually much more competetitive. It is more difficult to get into the top schools to do an MBA and the curriculum will be more rigorous in most cases. Many do an MBA after having completed an MSc. I think the "MBA" will open much more doors than any other graduate degree.

Jul 24, 2006 08:36

useful 0

reply

For comparision, how would an MA/Msc from a nice business school e.g Bradford compare with an MBA from say Luton,Reading Middlesex etc? Thx!
For comparision, how would an MA/Msc from a nice business school e.g Bradford compare with an MBA from say Luton,Reading Middlesex etc? Thx!

Jul 26, 2006 02:33

useful 0

reply


How about an MSC/MA in the management field from Edinburgh.....than an MBA from Reading, middlesex, essex, cardiff etc.
Please give some inputs.
How about an MSC/MA in the management field from Edinburgh.....than an MBA from Reading, middlesex, essex, cardiff etc. Please give some inputs.

asdc

0

37


Jul 27, 2006 10:05

useful 0

reply

Why would you do two pg degrees? I think you risk being 'overqualified', no?
Why would you do two pg degrees? I think you risk being 'overqualified', no?

Jul 27, 2006 11:32

useful 0

reply


oooo....u got me wrong....wat I meant was....Instead of doing MBA from Reading, Cardiff, Essex, Lincoln, Middlesex etc etc....is it not beetr to do an MSC in the magement field from University of Edinburgh or Cass Business School(City University).
oooo....u got me wrong....wat I meant was....Instead of doing MBA from Reading, Cardiff, Essex, Lincoln, Middlesex etc etc....is it not beetr to do an MSC in the magement field from University of Edinburgh or Cass Business School(City University).

asdc

0

37


Jul 28, 2006 10:36

useful 0

reply

Ok, I see. I am afraid I cannot really contribute anything regarding these schools. Anyone else?
Ok, I see. I am afraid I cannot really contribute anything regarding these schools. Anyone else?

RLC

0

8


Nov 06, 2006 01:39

useful 0

reply

Reconsider the MBA option? We are extremely competitive in terms of price. We are offering a one year University of Wales MBA at £6900. For more information have a look at our webpage.
http://www.rayatlondoncollege.co.uk/index.html
Reconsider the MBA option? We are extremely competitive in terms of price. We are offering a one year University of Wales MBA at £6900. For more information have a look at our webpage. http://www.rayatlondoncollege.co.uk/index.html

Martin_82

0

17


Feb 17, 2008 05:46

useful 0

reply

To refresh that thread:
I am from Germany, graduated engineer, aged 25 (work experience 6 months now). I have an offer for a MSc in Management in UK.
It was my second choice. Primary I want to study the MBA. Therefor I need more work experience at all.
So, what is the best choice I can do? I have read that a MBA is more respectable than a MSc right? Its just so confusing.

Any advice?
Best regards from Germany
To refresh that thread: I am from Germany, graduated engineer, aged 25 (work experience 6 months now). I have an offer for a MSc in Management in UK. It was my second choice. Primary I want to study the MBA. Therefor I need more work experience at all. So, what is the best choice I can do? I have read that a MBA is more respectable than a MSc right? Its just so confusing. Any advice? Best regards from Germany

lukeh

0

386


Feb 17, 2008 11:14

useful 0

reply

Hi Martin,

Typically the MSc emphases management in all its forms, while the MBA is more concerned with business strategy. The former is an academic degree, and therefore more theoretical, the latter is more professionally oriented. An MBA includes certain specialisations, while an MSc is more general. Neither one prevents entry into either academia or the professional world, however, but am MBA tends to be better recognised in the business world.
Hi Martin, Typically the MSc emphases management in all its forms, while the MBA is more concerned with business strategy. The former is an academic degree, and therefore more theoretical, the latter is more professionally oriented. An MBA includes certain specialisations, while an MSc is more general. Neither one prevents entry into either academia or the professional world, however, but am MBA tends to be better recognised in the business world.

Martin_82

0

17


Mar 25, 2008 10:02

useful 0

reply

Hi,

sorry for the delay answering to you.
Thanks. Well, to study the MBA I have to work 2-3 years. In my opinion I will never want to study after I get started working. Excepting I have my own business. Well, I have 6 months now until the Programme is starting. Enoiugh time to think about it.

But I have still one question. Is here anybody who hast studied a MSc in Management?

best regards from germany
Hi, sorry for the delay answering to you. Thanks. Well, to study the MBA I have to work 2-3 years. In my opinion I will never want to study after I get started working. Excepting I have my own business. Well, I have 6 months now until the Programme is starting. Enoiugh time to think about it. But I have still one question. Is here anybody who hast studied a MSc in Management? best regards from germany

fran

0

1


Nov 07, 2009 05:49

useful 0

reply

This is not true. Some facts:
-M.Sc. is more rigorous than MBA
-Student in M.Sc/Phd can be a teaching assistant (TA) in MBA classes. (Never seen student in MBA is a TA in M.Sc/Phd class.)
-We have excess supply of MBA, but shortage of M.Sc. This information can be found in AACSB.
-more, plz do ur own research

An MA or MSc in business will not be as marketable in the business world as an MBA degree. The MBA is usually much more competetitive. It is more difficult to get into the top schools to do an MBA and the curriculum will be more rigorous in most cases. Many do an MBA after having completed an MSc. I think the "MBA" will open much more doors than any other graduate degree.
This is not true. Some facts: -M.Sc. is more rigorous than MBA -Student in M.Sc/Phd can be a teaching assistant (TA) in MBA classes. (Never seen student in MBA is a TA in M.Sc/Phd class.) -We have excess supply of MBA, but shortage of M.Sc. This information can be found in AACSB. -more, plz do ur own research <blockquote>An MA or MSc in business will not be as marketable in the business world as an MBA degree. The MBA is usually much more competetitive. It is more difficult to get into the top schools to do an MBA and the curriculum will be more rigorous in most cases. Many do an MBA after having completed an MSc. I think the "MBA" will open much more doors than any other graduate degree.</blockquote>

aragorn123

0

64


Dec 14, 2009 11:04

useful 0

reply

MBA is better than only MSc Management!

Other specialized MSc Qualifications (e.g. Information Systems/EBusiness) could be more rigorous and intensive than MBA.

It also depends on the reputation of the University!

For Example, Master's degree from LSE could be in more demand than most of the MBAs!
MBA is better than only MSc Management! Other specialized MSc Qualifications (e.g. Information Systems/EBusiness) could be more rigorous and intensive than MBA. It also depends on the reputation of the University! For Example, Master's degree from LSE could be in more demand than most of the MBAs!

fre3ze

0

34


Dec 21, 2009 05:27

useful 0

reply

People often do an MSc because it does not require any prior work experience like an MBA.

Another reason for doing an MSc is because it is the first step towards doing a PHD and people who do a PHD would often like to undertake a career in research or teaching.

However, when it comes to job prospects, an MBA from a reputable university would hold more weightage than an MSc from a reputable university. As someone mentioned above an MBA curriculum is much more practical than an MSc.

But has anyone considered doing an MIB (Masters in International Business) which is a compressed version of an MBA i.e. its equally practical and dosen't require prior work experience ?

People often do an MSc because it does not require any prior work experience like an MBA. Another reason for doing an MSc is because it is the first step towards doing a PHD and people who do a PHD would often like to undertake a career in research or teaching. However, when it comes to job prospects, an MBA from a reputable university would hold more weightage than an MSc from a reputable university. As someone mentioned above an MBA curriculum is much more practical than an MSc. But has anyone considered doing an MIB (Masters in International Business) which is a compressed version of an MBA i.e. its equally practical and dosen't require prior work experience ?

robull34h

0

5


Jan 16, 2010 09:18

useful 0

reply

.
.

Jan 18, 2010 09:18

useful 0

reply

I am totally agreed with above conversation and statements

But on other option MSc is not bad if you have less work ex.

But seriously MSC much more tuff and expensive almost equally like MBA and admission process is VERY VERY HARD

IF you are going for MSc from Reading Said ,Jaudge,Edinburgh,LSE,LBS, Manchester,Ashridge
and it really have a worth
I am totally agreed with above conversation and statements But on other option MSc is not bad if you have less work ex. But seriously MSC much more tuff and expensive almost equally like MBA and admission process is VERY VERY HARD IF you are going for MSc from Reading Said ,Jaudge,Edinburgh,LSE,LBS, Manchester,Ashridge and it really have a worth

Zaid

0

4


Feb 25, 2010 02:40

useful 0

reply

am currently studying Msc in Management in Stirling Univ. and honestly we and the MBA students share about 80% of our modules...so i dont really beleive that the 2 extra modules they take will make them more practical or deeper into bussiness world than us...simply universities created such option btw MBA and MSC JUST FOR MONEY $$$ LOOL....so just they can attract more students from all financial levels :S poor and rich ! and one last thing ! Whether u have an Msc in management or an MBA...LUCK is everything...so dont panic about these two...just go ahead and choose the one that u can afford and start as early as possible...cheeeeeers
am currently studying Msc in Management in Stirling Univ. and honestly we and the MBA students share about 80% of our modules...so i dont really beleive that the 2 extra modules they take will make them more practical or deeper into bussiness world than us...simply universities created such option btw MBA and MSC JUST FOR MONEY $$$ LOOL....so just they can attract more students from all financial levels :S poor and rich ! and one last thing ! Whether u have an Msc in management or an MBA...LUCK is everything...so dont panic about these two...just go ahead and choose the one that u can afford and start as early as possible...cheeeeeers

Feb 25, 2010 05:07

useful 0

reply

Hiii, Can any1 help me out?? I am a 24 yr old professional with arnd 18 months workexp. I have done BE as my undergrads.
I have d followin offers:
1. MSc Management, Cass
2. MBus. Global Business Analysis, Manchester
3. MBM, Strathclyde
m also expectin an offer frm Warwick fr MSc Management

Q. Which one out f these is d best option fr me?
Q. Does MSc Management hold a good value, is it worth investing time & money? because a frnd frm Uk is tellin me tht MSc management wouldnt help me land up a job, I need to go fr specialst programs..
Q. I hav also heard tht in UK thers a lot f tax(arnd 40%), coupled with high living costs, so one is nt able to save up much workin ther.. is this true?
Kindly clear the air over these issues...
Hiii, Can any1 help me out?? I am a 24 yr old professional with arnd 18 months workexp. I have done BE as my undergrads. I have d followin offers: 1. MSc Management, Cass 2. MBus. Global Business Analysis, Manchester 3. MBM, Strathclyde m also expectin an offer frm Warwick fr MSc Management Q. Which one out f these is d best option fr me? Q. Does MSc Management hold a good value, is it worth investing time & money? because a frnd frm Uk is tellin me tht MSc management wouldnt help me land up a job, I need to go fr specialst programs.. Q. I hav also heard tht in UK thers a lot f tax(arnd 40%), coupled with high living costs, so one is nt able to save up much workin ther.. is this true? Kindly clear the air over these issues...

aki0010

0

1


Mar 24, 2010 10:54

useful 0

reply

Hi I am a undergraduate with no work experience I would like to know if a MBA from Cardiff University is better than MSc Finance from Warwick or Manchester University?

also the job prospectus after a cardiff mba?

please comment
Hi I am a undergraduate with no work experience I would like to know if a MBA from Cardiff University is better than MSc Finance from Warwick or Manchester University? also the job prospectus after a cardiff mba? please comment

acidtest

0

3


Jul 23, 2010 10:08

useful 0

reply

hello everyone...

I just got a definitive offer from IE for their Masters in International Management (sep intake).
Am really confused here as to how good or bad is it against an MBA,since i applied at IE for the IMBA course.
They suggested i take MIM since am 24 and have only 3 years work ex..

Please help me be sure....
hello everyone... I just got a definitive offer from IE for their Masters in International Management (sep intake). Am really confused here as to how good or bad is it against an MBA,since i applied at IE for the IMBA course. They suggested i take MIM since am 24 and have only 3 years work ex.. Please help me be sure....

Vale

0

1


Apr 08, 2011 08:19

useful 0

reply

I find the same thing. MBA and Msc have almost the same modules. It is just a money making business for the universities.
I find the same thing. MBA and Msc have almost the same modules. It is just a money making business for the universities.

mazumder

0

14


Oct 01, 2011 06:52

useful 0

reply

hey can any1 pls help me. i am a finance student in india. i dont have any work experience. i want to pursue my higher education in uk.
i want to work in london for couple of years and then will return to india to takeover family business. i am confused between msc in management and mba. is both the course same? will
msc management from either imperial college london or warwick etc be better than cardiff mba. more than degree value i want the depth of curriculum.
and also in many cases the course subjects are same for mba and msc management but is the detailed content of the subjects also same?
do i have to do mba again after msc management?
pls help me out.............
hey can any1 pls help me. i am a finance student in india. i dont have any work experience. i want to pursue my higher education in uk. i want to work in london for couple of years and then will return to india to takeover family business. i am confused between msc in management and mba. is both the course same? will msc management from either imperial college london or warwick etc be better than cardiff mba. more than degree value i want the depth of curriculum. and also in many cases the course subjects are same for mba and msc management but is the detailed content of the subjects also same? do i have to do mba again after msc management? pls help me out.............

Duncan

170

6135


Oct 01, 2011 09:35

useful 0

reply

The MSc from Imperial will be better than the Cardiff MBA. Only accredited MBAs, which require work experience, will be taken seriously. The accredited MSc graduates earn more than MBAs from unaccredited MBAs.
The MSc from Imperial will be better than the Cardiff MBA. Only accredited MBAs, which require work experience, will be taken seriously. The accredited MSc graduates earn more than MBAs from unaccredited MBAs.

mazumder

0

14


Oct 01, 2011 07:24

useful 0

reply

thnx a lot sir.......
can u tell me whether the knowledge given at msc management is same as mba??????
thnx a lot sir....... can u tell me whether the knowledge given at msc management is same as mba??????

Duncan

170

6135


Oct 02, 2011 04:34

useful 0

reply

I think it's hard to compare them. Accredited MBA and MSc programmes have very similar, comprehensive, core curriculums. At many schools with accredited MSc and MBA programmes the MSc curriculum is very similar to the MBA core curriculum. However, the MBA curriculum will be larger and will be more likely to involve internships, group projects and international exchanges.

On the other hand, unaccredited programmes tend to be less comprehensive and are weaker. That's why graduates from unaccredited programmes earn less.
I think it's hard to compare them. Accredited MBA and MSc programmes have very similar, comprehensive, core curriculums. At many schools with accredited MSc and MBA programmes the MSc curriculum is very similar to the MBA core curriculum. However, the MBA curriculum will be larger and will be more likely to involve internships, group projects and international exchanges. On the other hand, unaccredited programmes tend to be less comprehensive and are weaker. That's why graduates from unaccredited programmes earn less.

mazumder

0

14


Oct 02, 2011 07:48

useful 0

reply

Mr Duncan,
now the last question. being from a finance background and aiming to do family's industrial business, what would u suggest. msc management now or i should wait for some work experience and then take up mba
Mr Duncan, now the last question. being from a finance background and aiming to do family's industrial business, what would u suggest. msc management now or i should wait for some work experience and then take up mba

Duncan

170

6135


Oct 02, 2011 12:46

useful 0

reply

Well, you don't need to choose between them but, if you do, I'd suggest you focus on working, improving your GMAT and getting some good socially responsible volunteering done for a few years and then get into a top MBA.
Well, you don't need to choose between them but, if you do, I'd suggest you focus on working, improving your GMAT and getting some good socially responsible volunteering done for a few years and then get into a top MBA.

Nitz21

0

7


Jun 27, 2013 08:33

useful 0

reply

Hi Mr. Duncan,

Is freshers MBA from Cardiff University better than MSc in Finance from Exeter???
I want reply with respect to job prospects and joining family business.
Hi Mr. Duncan, Is freshers MBA from Cardiff University better than MSc in Finance from Exeter??? I want reply with respect to job prospects and joining family business.

Duncan

170

6135


Jun 27, 2013 03:48

useful 0

reply

Well, I think salaries will be higher for most graduates of that MSc in finance and investment than for any of the freshers' MBAs, especially since there is little demand for freshers MBA grads in the UK.

As for family business, whose family?
Well, I think salaries will be higher for most graduates of that MSc in finance and investment than for any of the freshers' MBAs, especially since there is little demand for freshers MBA grads in the UK. As for family business, whose family?

Nitz21

0

7


Jul 02, 2013 07:15

useful 0

reply

Thanks for your advice..........
By Family business i meant my own family business.
Thanks for your advice.......... By Family business i meant my own family business.

Duncan

170

6135


Jul 02, 2013 10:39

useful 0

reply

Well, that depends on the size of your family business. If there's space in your business for a financial leader then you'll make a big contribution there. AN MBA would be better for a general management role. If you're an Indian, and your family business is Indian, then Cardiff could be a good setting since most of the students there are Indian.
Well, that depends on the size of your family business. If there's space in your business for a financial leader then you'll make a big contribution there. AN MBA would be better for a general management role. If you're an Indian, and your family business is Indian, then Cardiff could be a good setting since most of the students there are Indian.

Reply to Post